A Brighter Horizon and a Fractured Forest

Written by Dale Sinclair

I stood in the backcountry of Frontenac Provincial Park just as the November freeze began to harden the mud. The air held a sharp, crystalline bite that clears the mind and sharpens the senses. I kept my camera close, eager to capture the stark, quiet beauty of the changing season, finding a strange thrill in the honest cold. Out here, where the ancient granite of the Canadian Shield rises toward the Adirondack Mountains, the silence is profound. It is a vast, enveloping quiet that reminds you of the deep spirit of the woods. The wilderness here has teeth, but it rewards those who respect it with a breathtaking solitude. Soon, however, that peace could be shattered by the tearing rush of a high-speed train.

Frontenac Provincial Park. Photo Courtesy of Dale Sinclair.

We are standing on the precipice of a monumental shift. The federal government is advancing the Alto high-speed rail network, laying approximately 1,000 kilometres of electrified passenger track from Toronto to Quebec City. It promises profound liberation and a massive reduction in our carbon footprint by pulling travelers out of cars and airplanes. It is a necessary leap forward for a growing nation.

This brings us to the turn in our modern reckoning. Alto represents an environmental triumph for human emissions, yet it is a deeply cynical reality for the wilderness it must cut through. Here in the expanse of the Frontenac Arch, planners are still debating whether the train will roar north or south of the park boundaries. Whichever line they draw, it will intersect a fragile world.

The Arch is not just a rocky ridge. It is a globally recognized UNESCO Biosphere Reserve and the beating heart of the Algonquin to Adirondack ecological corridor. The Anishinaabe and Haudenosaunee peoples have stewarded these lands for millennia, understanding this geography not as real estate to be divided, but as a continuous, breathing entity. We are merely guests here, slowly re-learning the delicate balance required to exist within it.

• 

  Overlay of the Alto high speed rail study area. The proposed southern route would cut right through the Frontenac Arch Biosphere Region. Photo Courtesy of Dale Sinclair.

To understand the stakes, we only need to look at the legendary journey of Alice. In 1998, researchers collared a 700-pound female moose in New York's Adirondack Park. Over the next three years, driven by a ghost of an instinct, Alice walked north. She traversed forests, swam the mighty St. Lawrence River, and miraculously navigated the deadly gauntlet of Highway 401. She eventually died in Algonquin Provincial Park in 2001. Alice proved that the corridor is not just an abstract theory on a conservationist's map. It is blood and bone. It is a vital, desperate lifeline.

A rail line running at 300 kilometres per hour is a heavily fortified wall. Proposed ground-level tracks demand a cleared corridor sixty meters wide, guarded by continuous wire fencing with buried skirts. For wide-ranging mammals like the moose, the black bear, and the Eastern wolf, this creates an impenetrable barrier that severs their historic territories. By choosing to carve a completely new path rather than co-locating the tracks alongside the existing barrier of Highway 401, we are choosing to inflict a second, devastating cut across the biosphere.

Rendering of the Alto high speed train. Tall fences will create a barrier for animals attempting to move through the corridor. Photo courtesy of Alto.

If we build Alto, we cannot simply lay steel and look away. We must demand infrastructure that accommodates the original travelers of this land. Tracks must be fully elevated on viaducts through the Arch to allow the forest to breathe and its wildlife to move freely beneath them. Where ground-level tracks are absolutely unavoidable, we need to construct dedicated, vegetated wildlife overpasses designed to coax a hesitant wolf across the chasm of human noise.

In the context of a rail project estimated to cost tens of billions of dollars, integrating a network of overpasses and elevating tracks through the Frontenac Arch is a rounding error. It is the absolute minimum price of admission for building through one of the last great wild arteries of eastern North America. 

Lethbridge Viaduct in Alberta, Canada. Elevated rail tracks allow animals to move freely below the tracks. Photo courtesy of CSCE.

What can we do? If we cannot stop the train, we must shape how it is built. But we can shape how it is built. The window to act is narrow. Until March 29th, you can submit public comments to the Alto project planners demanding that the rail line be fully elevated through priority movement corridors or co-located with Highway 401. Support the A2A Collaborative and local conservation groups protecting these ancient pathways. We must ensure that as we build a bridge to our future, we do not permanently sever the ancient trails that keep this wild land alive.

Learn more about Alto.